Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Police: Step Away From the Cow.

AN OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY student journalist was detained and arrested by university police when he wouldn't stop photographing runaway cows.

The student, who shoots pictures for the school newspaper, heard that a pair of cows from the agriculture school were loose and roaming campus. So he grabbed his gear and ran to the scene.

Someone from the agriculture school told him he wasn't allowed to take pictures. The student journalist said that he was on public property and allowed to take pictures.

University police later told the student that he could not take pictures from where he was because he was in danger. The student journalist moved and continued shooting elsewhere. He continued shooting as the cows ran. At one point, the student journalist bypassed a police barricade by walking through a university building.

Did the student journalist do a good job by getting the images? Or were the police correct - the student journalist put himself in danger by not listening to police?

Friday, April 23, 2010

Jackie Larma: "People Will Have a View of the World Because of Your Pictures."

JACKIE LARMA SPENT so long in Israel, working as a photojournalist, that the place feels like home to her. Raised in Texas, she was immersed in the struggles and daily life of Israel for 17 years. She visually documented activity in the Middle East, and also traveled to Europe and Africa to tell stories from there. She won a Pulitzer Prize in 1995 for her images documenting the struggles of Rwandan refugees.

Now, she serves as the photo editor for the Associated Press here in Philadelphia. Here are a few things she said during her visit to class:

- She didn't have worked lined up in Israel after college. She just went.
- Before she went, however, she met with editors in the United States to make connections.
- "It's hard to remain neutral," she said of documenting struggles and conflicts. "Being neutral is ignorant, in some way."

- A journalist has to learn to deal with conflict and death in a professional way.
- "People will have a view of the world because of your pictures," she said of photojournalists. "That is a huge responsibility."


- She says that witnessing violence does not numb you. It makes you more sensitive to it.
- The images she created do not haunt her. But she thinks about those people every day.
- If she saw a person in trouble, she would help them. But she wouldn't become the story like Anderson Cooper did. "He's doing a job," Jackie said of Cooper. "He's going to leave when the next big story comes along."

- Photojournalism is the exact same job as being a reporter or broadcaster. You just use different tools to gather and tell stories.
- The best journalists avoid filters - rather than get official statements, talk to those who were immediately impacted.
- She would not lie to get stories or access to information. That is against the Associated Press' code of ethics.
- She did joke with a police officer once, saying she worked for Playgirl.
- She has been detained by authorities on multiple occasions. She knew that her phones were often tapped.
- Danger surrounded her during her job. And, while serving as a photo editor, she frequently sent other photographers into harm's way.
- Being a journalist is similar to being a firefighter. "Journalism is just like any public service," she said. "We're civil servants."

What stood out for you?

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Your Cereal Reflects You as a Person.

TEACHING ASSISTANT Kelly George, a doctoral student in the School of Communications and Theater, lectured today on advertising and its relationship with journalism. Here are a few things that stood out for me:

- "Communications is a symbolic process whereby reality is produced, maintained, repaired and transformed" (as stated by James Carey).
- Advertising can create consumerism but consumerism also already exists in society.
- Advertising began in a rational fashion. Today, most advertising now appeals to the audience's emotions (for example, the Broadview Security ad, which was parodied by Saturday Night Live).

- The history of advertising parallels the history of journalism.
- The first advertising agency was created in Philadelphia in 1869.
- Railroads connected the east and west coasts, creating a national mass audience.
- Magazines were the first media to take advantage of and serve that national audience.

- Advertising relies on a prosperous economy.
- The creative side of advertising became very influential after World War II.
- Advertising often relies upon stereotypes to make a connection to the audience.
- Advertising has the ability to strengthen connections, forming community.

Kelly talked about a Wal-Mart employee who was trampled by Black Friday shoppers. Who was responsible for that man's death? Advertisers? Journalists who rely upon advertising to support their endeavors? The shoppers?

What stood out for you?

Monday, April 19, 2010

Should Journalists Cooperate With the Police?

FOUR TIMES THE number of expected revelers showed up at an annual outdoor party near James Madison University last week. When police tried to disperse the crowd, a riot broke out. Around 40 people were injured, mostly from flying beer bottles and other thrown objects. Around 30 arrests were made.

Local police asked the JMU newspaper to provide their images of the event, ostensibly so that the police could identify suspects. The newspaper editor declined.

"I said that the only ones that we were going to release at this time were the ones that were on our Web site and the ones that were already published," the editor says she told police, according to the Roanoke Times. "I didn't feel like it was our responsibility to give information to the police and be the investigators for them."

On Friday, police arrived at the newspaper office with a search warrant and downloaded all of the newspaper's images.

Should the editor and staff have cooperated from the beginning? Or were they right in telling the cops they should do their own dirty work?

(The image above was shot by the local police department. They had their own photographers on the scene as well.)

Journalists and the Law: Where is the Line Between Reporting and Doing Police Work?

PROTECTING SOURCES is a longstanding tradition in journalism. Had Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward (above) revealed their primary source during the Watergate scandal, President Richard Nixon may have remained in office and the corruption of that era may have continued.

More recently, former New York Times reporter Judith Miller spent three months in jail rather than reveal the source of her information (which she never even published).

Investigative journalists dig for information, often about people in powerful positions. Their role is to uncover misbehavior. But they are not law enforcement.

This became an issue in France recently after a broadcast journalist went online in chat rooms posing as a 12-year old girl in order to lure pedophiles. The story led to 20 arrests after the reporter and his producers notified police of their findings.

Did the journalists confuse their role in society? Were they grandstanding by taking their information to the police? Is this "gotcha" journalism?

Or are there limits on who journalists protect when it comes to informants?

Was it wrong for the journalist to lie about his identity in order to gain information?

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

"You Got to Have Passion to be a Columnist."

EUGENE KANE WANTS TO save the world. And it all started because Kane, a Dobbins and Temple grad, thought the media portrayed his North Philly neighborhood in an unrealistic manner. He became a journalist to alter people's opinions about the world.

Here are a few things that stood out for me from his visit to class:

- He says that columnists can't straddle the fence. They need to take one side and support their opinion.
- Many of his columns stem from news events. He does further reporting for his column.
- "You got to have passion to be a columnist," he said.
- Journalists can't ever be completely objective, he believes. They are subjective simply by choosing what stories to write.
- "If you have any curiosity at all, it's fairly easy to find column ideas," he said.

- The idea of being post-racial is absurd, he said. "Race is still a pretty big issues in America."
- A reader recently called him a "racist imbecile."
- "A lot of people will not like anything you do," Kane said. "You got to have thick skin to be a columnist. You shouldn't be in journalism if you don't have thick skin."
- He wants his columns to stir a reaction. If they do not evoke a reaction, what is the point?

- "Print will never die," he said.
- He remembers the days when you could smoke in the newsroom.
- Twitter is not a frivolous media unless you treat it like a frivolous media, Kane stated.
- He is not "The Angry Black columnist." He writes about social issues, which often deal with the African-American community.
- The media tend to portray minorities in a negative light, he said.
- If you are interested in becoming a columnist, you need to develop your voice and perspective.
- Blogs are a way to develop that voice.
- Focus on what you know, he said.
- Get an internship. Now.
- Combined with Bill Cosby, Kane is worth more than $300 million.

What stood out for you?

Monday, April 12, 2010

Should Websites Ban Anonymous Commenters?

EUGENE KANE OF THE Milwaukee Journal Sentinel recently wrote about anonymous commenters posting extreme opinions on news websites:

"The blogosphere's popularity over the last decade or so seems to have avoided the requirement for credibility for commenters. As a result, people feel free to comment on whatever they want, however they want, and in many cases, as offensively as they want. Some of them talk big smack, mainly because nobody knows their name."


Should readers be allowed to leave comments without leaving some sort of verifiable identity? Does a lack of identity only breed radical dialogue?

Some people argue that journalists frequently use anonymous sources in stories. Is there any difference?

Post your thoughts in the comments section below. Please leave your name.

And read more of Eugene Kane's work here. Kane (pictured above with Bill Cosby) is a Temple grad who will visit class on Tuesday.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Should the Killer Whale Video Be Released?

A KILLER WHALE killed a trainer at SeaWorld during a performance in February. Security video captured the entire episode. Should it be made available to the public and shown on broadcast news (and the Internet)?

The video was taken into custody by sheriffs, and therefore became a part of the public record. A judge put a temporary ban on the film's release, appeasing the family of the victim and SeaWorld staffers. Over the past week, the two sides were trying to negotiate a deal for the media to see the footage but not publish or air it.

Is there any benefit to the public by showing the video? Does the public have the right to see it? Should the media be allowed to access what is now public record? Or does the family have a right to seal the video showing the death of their loved one?

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Can you Go A Day Without News?

HAVE YOU EVER NOTICED that the news fits perfectly in the space of a 30-minute newscast, every day?

Or, as Jerry Seinfeld said, "It's amazing that the amount of news that happens in the world every day always just exactly fits the newspaper."

Do you ever get the idea that sometimes you are getting stuff just to fill the space/ time - info about Tiger's "Transgressions" and the like?

In the age of the Internet, do you feel overloaded with info? Is the news cycle/ production schedule of newspapers and broadcast news outdated? Are the traditional news outlets making themselves irrelevant because they treat people like morons?

Can you do a day without traditional news? How about a week?

Monday, April 5, 2010

What's the Big Sports Story? (Or, Lesson Number One for How to be an Evil PR Person).

THE EAGLES TRADED away their former first-round draft pick who led the team for 11 seasons. They sent him to a division rival. Late Sunday evening. Easter Sunday. The day before the Phillies season opener, where superstar pitcher Roy Halladay was set to make his National League debut. With Barack Obama throwing the ceremonial first pitch.

Oh, and that guy Tiger Woods is returning to the links this week after a five-month hiatus ... because he was having an affair with a few women.

If you ran a news outlet, which story would you lead with and why?

As a second question, do you think the Eagles announced their trade yesterday thinking the story would receive less criticism than during a slow sports news day? It does sort of take a monumental event for the team and bury it in a world of other news.

Finally, do you think the Eagles were trying to steal the thunder from the Phillies?

Thursday, April 1, 2010

April Fools Joke? Glenn Beck Fans Towed.

THIS ISN'T A JOURNALISM ethics issue at all. But it is amusing. Enjoy.