Subsets of Voters: Good Journalism or Widening the Divide?
OVER THE LAST few weeks, the Philadelphia Inquirer has profiled gay voters, evangelical Christian voters and Jewish voters in connection to the presidential race.
Personally, I'm offended. It's easy for the media (and politicians) to group people together. But those ideas are massive generalizations. Just because you are Jewish does not mean you will vote like other Jewish people. Same for gays, evangelical Christians, African-Americans, women and every other subset of the American population.
I think its ignorant of the media to say that the Jews, gays, or anyone else for that matter is leaning one way or the other. We are all individuals.
- George (the classic Asian-American, urban-dwelling, dog-loving, bicycling voter)
I understand that political groups do it for "studies" so candidates can better appeal to these "groups" but it's just an easy solution for them that's not actually going to give them the results they're looking for because, as mentioned above, we are all individuals.
But for a publication to subcategorize their readers this way is offensive. Not to mention bad for business...
If you intend to go into journalism as a career, you should be writing, taking pictures, laying out pages, making decisions and informing our community now. Really.
Contact an editor at the Temple News and begin working for them ASAP. Get clips. Get experience. Get paid.
Former CBS3 anchor Larry Mendte visited our class in 2008 and then put us on the news. He polled the class on the day of the Pennsylvania Primary Election. You can see the video by clicking here.
3 comments:
Seriously? No one has any thoughts on this?
Personally, I'm offended. It's easy for the media (and politicians) to group people together. But those ideas are massive generalizations. Just because you are Jewish does not mean you will vote like other Jewish people. Same for gays, evangelical Christians, African-Americans, women and every other subset of the American population.
I think its ignorant of the media to say that the Jews, gays, or anyone else for that matter is leaning one way or the other. We are all individuals.
- George (the classic Asian-American, urban-dwelling, dog-loving, bicycling voter)
I agree.
I understand that political groups do it for "studies" so candidates can better appeal to these "groups" but it's just an easy solution for them that's not actually going to give them the results they're looking for because, as mentioned above, we are all individuals.
But for a publication to subcategorize their readers this way is offensive. Not to mention bad for business...
Thanks Emily. I was feeling awfully lonely there with no one commenting!
- George (the teacher and individual)
Post a Comment